I was super worried that Harestar would continue Onestar’s idiocy, but I’m happy he isn’t. He was fiercely loyal to WindClan, so what the actual heck, Erin Hunter crew. He would not have gotten a cat pregnant or even had a thing for a cat outside the clans. They’re basically two different characters. Onewhisker at that point in time did not act like Onestar. He was a coward and had a fling? The whole “oooh, Darktail is his son” was stupid and made me super pissed. ![]() It made zero sense to me that he turned against Firestar and ThunderClan, and even the rest of the clans. Onewhisker used to be one of my favorite characters of all time, and I absolutely hate his leader story arc. When Onestar died in the end of book three, I’m not going to lie, I was happy, and that made me super sad. (I will say this is becoming a nightmare with all of the clans being butthurt over stuff). RiverClan: What the bloody heck are you doing in this book. Finally–FINALLY–Sk圜lan is back with the clans! You guys have no idea how excited I am that this has happened in the books. I have been waiting for this moment since Firestar’s Quest. ShadowClan warriors are still acting disrespectful to him (gee, isn’t that why Darktail was able to come in so easily?), and I honestly cannot understand why they acted that way in the beginning. They’re down to less than half of their clan, and Rowanstar is losing his courage. until the first Gathering meeting, I thought they still had a fairly good number of warriors left, but no. I was not expecting ShadowClan to be as destroyed as it was. She is still acting like a brat (yes, I think she’s a brat in the other books–after how she behaves in ShadowClan and her “superior” attitude over the situation with Darktail nearly got her killed). I didn’t like it, and half of her conversations felt stupid, I’m sorry. ![]() I get why her feelings are so mixed about being either Sk圜lan or ThunderClan, but most of her POV felt like it was simply a way for us to see into Sk圜lan while everything else was happening. Firstly, my complaints against this: Sk圜lan gets their new territory (not surprising), but I feel like Twigpaw’s arc in this entire book was useless. Okay, guys, so this wasn’t the most exciting edition of Warriors, but it was way better than the Dawn of the Clans books, and had more action, too. Truthfully, I’m confused why this book got so many bad reviews on Amazon! I personally loved it, though I will agree that it read more as a filler than anything else, but considering how book three of Vision of Shadow ended, it makes sense why there would be a slight lull before the explosion that we all know will occur in books five and six.īefore I continue, there is a spoiler warning, so stop now if you have not read books 1-3 of Vision of Shadows.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |